Best Pizza in Surfside Beach, SC | Sea Star Realty

You are here

24 Jul 2019
Related Items: 
Best of Surfside Beach

It seems like every vacation to the East Coast starts with "I'm going to eat ALL the seafood", and ends with "I just want pizza". Trust me, we love our crabcakes, shrimp boils and all-you-can-eat seafood buffets, but sometimes there's nothing like pizza after a long day of adventure in South Carolina. Surfside Beach is all about family, and nothing says family quite like a pizza party. So go ahead and take a break from seafood with our top picks for the best pizza in Surfside Beach, SC!

Best Pizza in Surfside Beach, SC at a Glance

  1. Mellow Mushroom
  2. The Original Valentino Italian Restaurant
  3. Surfside Beach Pizza
  4. Ultimate California Pizza
  5. Lazer's Pizza

Best Pizza in Surfside Beach, SC Details

#1 - Mellow Mushroom

Friends enjoying a melty cheese pizza together

Mellow Mushroom offers a little bit of everything, and serves up some especially delicious pizza. Choose from speciality pies, build-your-own pies, calzones, hoagies, salads, appetizers and desserts. Their Buffalo Chicken Pizza comes with Applewood Smoked Bacon and their Holy Shitake Pie is vegetarian friendly. They can make any pizza gluten-free upon request and their menu shows nutritional information so you know exactly what you're getting. 

More About Mellow Mushroom

#2 - The Original Valentino Italian Restaurant

Sicilian square pizza in South Carolina

The Original Valentino Italian Restaurant is perfect if you're looking for some classy Italian fare in a low-key environment. Their menu is huge and they offer favorites like Chicken Piccata and Manicotti. Their pizza menu is build-your-own pizza all the way, and you can choose between a round pizza or a Sicilian-style (square) crust. They have all the classic toppings available, and you can pair your meal with wine or beer. 

More About The Original Valentino Italian Restaurant

#3 - Surfside Beach Pizza

Boy holding a big pizza and smelling it

Surfside Beach Pizza is quick, casual and mighty tasty. This restaurant offers an extensive menu with plenty of options for everyone. Choose from pizza, calzones, hot or cold hoagie sandwhiches, pasta, chicken entrees, veal entrees, seafood entrees and Italian classic entrees. Their Pizza menu offers both specialty pies and build-your-own pizzas. They also offer a gluten-free crust and there is beer available for the adults.

More About Surfside Beach Pizza

#4 - Ultimate California Pizza

Chef making a pizza

Ultimate California Pizza serves up delicious pizza and offers creative twists on our beloved pie. There is a full menu of appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and pizza. The Cheesy Stuf't Breadsticks will delight cheese lovers, and they've been voted Best Pizza in Myrtle Beach before. You can build-your-own pizza or try out one of their daring combinations like a meatball pizza or a Mexicali Nacho-Style Pizza.

More About Ultimate California Pizza

#5 - Lazer's Pizza

Lazer's Pizza made the list of our favorite pizza places by popular demand - and honestly we're a little embarrased we didn't add them in the first place! This family owned and operated business brings some serious taste to the table and they offer a great selection of dishes. Choose from pizza, subs, calzones, pasta, wraps, salads, cheesesteaks, stromboli and more. Try their Tropical pizza on a hot day or keep it fresh with the Mediterranean. 

More About Lazers Pizza

Want More Surfside Beach?

We've got all the details on Surfside Beach, like which events to attend, what activities to enjoy and which vacation homes have the best private pools. Learn all about where Surfside Beach is and what makes it so great, and reserve your Surfside vacation home now.

Browse Surfside Beach Vacation Homes